Morality of Trump immigration, refugee policies sparks pitched debate

The debate over immigration, border control, and refugee resettlement remains a hot-button topic among the general population, including U.S. Catholics, who have a wide range of stances on the issue. An array of policymakers, theologians, and representatives for Catholic aid organizations have shared their takes on the topic with CNA.

In the wake of the Trump administration’s funding cuts, Catholic aid organizations such as Catholic Charities and Jesuit Refugee Service (JRS) USA have been outspoken in their advocacy for the restoration of aid to their programs, which benefit migrants and refugees. As part of the 90-day funding freeze, over $18 million in federal federal funding to JRS USA was frozen, though aid to select programs has since been reauthorized. Catholic Charities across the country have shuttered refugee services and other programs due to the freeze.

At a JRS USA-sponsored conference late last month, Kevin Appleby, former director of migration policy for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and current senior director of international migration policy for the Center for Migration Studies, weighed in on the divide between the U.S. bishops and the administration.

“I always believe that dialogue is important,” he told CNA. “I don’t think the Church should wait for four years. We have to try to engage the administration as much as possible because by doing that, you can help refugees.” Appleby indicated there are areas where the Church and administration might find common ground, such as in combatting human trafficking.

At that same conference, Washington, D.C.’s Cardinal Robert McElroy emphasized that “we’ve got to remember the call of Jesus is constant, to always be attentive to the needs and the suffering that lie around us, to perceive it, and then to act,” he said, comparing the plight of migrants to the robbers’ victim in the parable of the good Samaritan.

The cardinal archbishop criticized the Trump administration’s foreign aid suspension, describing it as “unconscionable through any prism of Catholic thought” and “moral theft from the poorest and the most desperate men, women, and children in our world today.” While acknowledging the need for border control, McElroy condemned mass deportation efforts and called for legislation that supports “generous asylum and refugee policy.”

Read More…